Join our weekly Peninim on the Torah list!

“Behold! he was standing over the River… ‘In my dream, behold! I was standing upon the bank of the River.’” (41:1, 17)

Download PDF

In Pharaoh’s dream, he sees himself standing over the river. When he relates the dream to Yosef, he tells him that he was standing on the bank  of  the river. What  is  the  significance  of  this discrepancy? The commentators suggest reasons for the change. Horav Yaakov Neiman, z.l., takes a somewhat different approach. He gives the following analogy. In America, during the cold winter rivers and lakes freeze, due to the subzero temperatures. When these rivers freeze, they become rock solid. One can  even drive over these frozen “highways.” Someone who comes from a warm climate and sees this “highway,” will not think twice about building a house on this hard ground. If he does so, we understand that as soon as the weather warms up and the thaw begins, he will have a house on the water.

The analogy is obvious. One who builds in this temporary world is similar to he who builds on the frozen river. When the day arrives that he leaves this world, everything that he has built will crumble and disintegrate. This world is temporary, so that whatever one invests in Olam Hazeh, if it  has no spiritual value will dissipate with time.

The Torah alludes to this in our parshah. When Pharaoh slept, when his dreams became confused with reality, he thought that he was standing over the river. Everything is in his hands; he is in charge; he is the boss. As soon as his “wake-up” call comes to prepare him to leave this world, he realizes that what he had was nothing more than a figment of his imagination. He has nothing! He is not over the river; rather, he barely touches the shore.

When a man enters this world as a little infant, his hands are clenched as if to imply that he is prepared to grab hold of everything that he can.  When  he  leaves  this  world,  however,  his  hands  are  wide  open, demonstrating that this world contains nothing. One leaves empty-handed. He only takes with him those deeds that have enduring spiritual value.

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Join our weekly Peninim on the Torah list!

You have Successfully Subscribed!